may 3rd 2016 patients rights have no borders as well as risks

Patients would access cross-border healthcare services when adequate healthcare treatments are not available in their home country, when the relative services are managed better elsewhere or when the nearest available healthcare treatment is in another Member State, as happen in the case of many border areas.
Currently, cross-border healthcare accounts for approximately 1% of the overall EU public health spending – around €10 billion per year.

According to the Special Eurobarometer 425 on “Patients’ rights in cross-border healthcare in the European Union” published in May 2015, only 5% of people living in the EU have received medical treatments in another European country in the last year. The report shows that in the majority of cases patients had not planned to benefit from cross-border medical treatment. Indeed, among these, only 2% of them received treatment in a foreign country because they had actually planned to do so, while 3% of patients needed to be treated unexpectedly when already abroad.

The World Health Organization report on “Cross-Border Healthcare in Europe” also underlines that the volume of patient mobility within the European Union is relatively low because individuals are unwilling to travel to other countries for healthcare. But in the areas where patient mobility is high, issues related to the impact of cross-border healthcare services on patients, health professionals and health systems are more relevant.

The report on the state of play of the Cross-border Healthcare Directive (CBHC), published by the European Commission in September 2015, clearly shows that the European citizens’ awareness about their right to seek healthcare in another EU country remains low and only the 10% of European citizens are aware of the National Contact Points (NCPs).

Indeed, less than 20% of them feel that they are informed about their cross-border healthcare rights and just the 2% take advantage of these rights and go abroad when more qualified and specialized healthcare centres are available.

These aspects have increased the consciousness that a better coordination of healthcare policies across the EU is needed and the impact of the Directive 2011/24/EU will depend largely on the knowledge that patients have of their rights under the law,also in relation to the cross-border healthcare access and repayments.

Moreover, an appropriate implementation of the Directive will also help the remaining 98% of people that decide to stay, or cannot move from their country for personal reasons, to get a better quality and high standards of healthcare services at local level. So, the correct implementation of the Directive 2011/24/EU will give advantages to all patients and will enhance cooperation between Member States.

Furthermore, is important to underline that a proper communication towards citizens and patients concerning the opportunities provided by the Directive on cross-borders healthcare has to include a careful analysis on the related potential risks and possible uncomfortable situations that foreign patients could face as misunderstandings, fraud, deceptions, etc.

The meeting was a debate among civic and patient associations from different Member States, experts in the field of civil rights, Institutional representatives, National Contact Points and several stakeholders at EU level.

It was held on 3 May 2016 at the European Parliament in Brussels and was hosted by MEP David Borrelli, Co-Chair of the EFDD Group and Co-Founder of the Interest Group.

Download the programme and the presentations of the meeting.

For more information, please write an email to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.